Gaf Natural shadow charcoal vs hd charcoal

Is there any contractors that have used the Gaf Natural Shadow shingles? Looking at the pictures the charcoal color in the Natural shadow seems a little dull in color compared to the hd. just curious

Same shingle as HD without the shadow line basically. And it’s cheaper. Same mat, same asphalt as HD though!

Icon, Your observation is correct.

Thank you! I think its a good shingle to upgrade customers who have 3 tab shingles on their homes bc of the price. As far as having a broad color or using them on nicer homes i’m not sure.

Where I am, natural Shadow pricing is only for $5 a square lower, so it hardly seems worth it to offer.