Shingle Choices

The choices are GAF Timberline, Certainteed Landmark Woodscape and Tamko Heritage. They are all 30 year dimensional shingles. The cost for each is about the same. Can you give me some pros and cons of why you would choose one over another and also rate them on a 10 point scale and I do realize that is arbitrary.

Certainteed period.

Its been said before, but top item on your list should be a quality installation. We all have our own opinions about what brands we like best but bottom line is nearly all of them will perform well when installed correctly.

GAF Timberlne is th best laminate on the market.

CERTAINTEED LANDMARK best on the market :smiley:

They are correct in saying product installation is as important as product quality.Both manufactures have great extended warranties.,You could have 2 different
contractors installing 2 different types of materials,
One installing a cheap 20yr 3-tab and one the GrandManor 100yr lifetime, but if the installer of the 3-tab installs correctly versus the improper install of the grandManor then obviously the 20yr will be the better choice,pick the shingles/colors that best fits your needs and will perform the best in your climate.,roof components (vents,felt,moisture guard) are as equally important as shingles/colors.Then pick the contractor that will install your roof system properly.

pick the one you like the look, and color of best. its your house, and they are ALL a quality product.